Light-filled living room with linen sofa, blue accents and oak furniture overlooking a leafy lawn and late-autumn trees.

Reading Hamilton's Fall Market From the Allegan County Numbers

Hamilton sits in Allegan County, and Zeeland sits in Ottawa County, a short drive north. On paper this fall, the housing market looks different on each side of that county line. In October 2026, Allegan County's median sale price was $340,000, down 6.2% from October 2025. Ottawa County's was $430,000, up 7.5% over the same stretch, according to the West Michigan Lakeshore Association of REALTORS® October 2026 report. September looked the same. Allegan's median fell 5.3% year over year and Ottawa's rose 6.1%, per WMLAR's September 2026 report.

If you're deciding between a home around Hamilton and one around Zeeland or Holland, it's easy to read that as one side of the line getting cheaper and the other getting pricier. Neither median says that. Both prices are moving because of which homes sold. The number that did move on its own this fall is the count of signed contracts, and it grew on the Hamilton side of the line.

Two months, side by side

WMLAR reports by county, so the closest view of Hamilton is Allegan County and the closest view of Zeeland and most of Holland is Ottawa County. Here are both counties for the two most recent months, with each figure compared to the same month in 2025.

Measure Allegan, Sept. 2026 Allegan, Oct. 2026 Ottawa, Sept. 2026 Ottawa, Oct. 2026
Closed sales 110, down 7.6% 101, down 1% 211, down 24% 191, down 20%
Median sale price $360,000, down 5.3% $340,000, down 6.2% $430,000, up 6.1% $430,000, up 7.5%
Dollar volume $60 million, up 19% $47 million, down 7.8% $111 million, down 19% $98 million, down 15%
Active listings 291, up 7.4% 302, up 11% 481, up 22% 468, up 10%
Avg. days on market 30, up 15% 30, down 9.1% 30, up 3.4% 33, up 3.1%

The medians pull apart in both months, so it isn't a one-month blip. The sales counts tell the more useful story. In October, Ottawa closed a fifth fewer homes than a year earlier, while Allegan closed almost as many as it did in October 2025.

Ottawa's median rose because fewer homes sold

A median is the midpoint of the prices of whatever closed that month. If 20% fewer homes sell and the missing ones are mostly at the lower end, the middle moves up even when no house is worth a dollar more than it was. Ottawa's numbers fit that pattern. In October 2026, closed sales were down 20% and dollar volume was down 15%. Dollar volume fell less than the sale count did, which is what you'd expect if the homes that still sold leaned toward higher prices.

Mortgage rates help explain who stepped back. WMLAR cites Freddie Mac's national average at 7.24% as of October 29, 2026, up from 6.17% a year earlier. A month before that, the rate was 7.28% as of October 1, 2026, compared with 6.34% a year earlier. That full extra point lands hardest on buyers stretching to reach Ottawa's price levels. WMLAR CEO Jon Broadbooks said in the September release that "the surge in interest rates in the past month puts additional pressure on buyers as they may be worrying about future upward rate shifts."

For a Zeeland or Holland seller, a $430,000 county median doesn't mean every house gained 7%. It means the homes that closed were a pricier group than a year ago.

Allegan's median fell even with more luxury sales

The Allegan side is less intuitive. Allegan County takes in both Saugatuck-Douglas on the lakeshore and Hamilton inland, so its median blends very different homes. In the third quarter of 2026, Allegan recorded 32 sales of $1 million or more, up 113% from a year earlier, at a median of $1.5 million, according to WMLAR's Q3 2026 luxury report. Ottawa recorded 35 luxury sales, down 17%.

You'd expect more seven-figure sales to pull a median up. Allegan's went down anyway, which means the middle of the county's market was filled by more modestly priced homes than a year earlier. September shows both forces in the same month. Allegan closed 7.6% fewer homes, its median fell 5.3%, and its dollar volume rose 19% to $60 million. With fewer sales bringing in more total dollars, the average sale got larger even as the median sale got smaller.

So a Hamilton homeowner shouldn't read the $340,000 October figure as a price cut on their own street. The county median puts a Saugatuck-Douglas lakeshore sale and a Hamilton-area sale into the same number. Neither the drop nor the rise measures what a particular three-bedroom in 49419 is worth.

Where the market moved: signed contracts

Price medians respond to the mix of homes that sold. Contract counts show whether buyers are signing at all. In September 2026, Allegan County recorded 129 pending sales, up 18% from September 2025. Ottawa recorded 249, down 12%, per WMLAR's September pending sales report. WMLAR describes pending sales as a forward-looking indicator of what may happen over the next 60 days.

October closings fit that forecast. Allegan's closed sales were nearly flat year over year, down 1%, and its average days on market dropped 9.1% to 30 days. Ottawa's closings fell 20%, and its average days on market rose 3.1% to 33. On the Allegan side, homes were going under contract faster this October than last. On the Ottawa side, they were taking a little longer.

Put the three measures together and you get one picture. With rates above 7%, the side of the county line with the lower typical price point held on to its buyers. The Ottawa side, where the typical sale runs about $90,000 higher, lost more of them. Many of the homes those buyers chose in Allegan were moderately priced, so the Allegan median went down because more of them sold.

What this means around Hamilton this winter

Inventory grew on both sides. Allegan had 302 active listings in October 2026, up 11%, and Ottawa had 468, up 10%. Broadbooks put it this way in the October release: "Rising inventory is giving buyers more options, but fewer sales show that the market continues to adjust. Conditions vary by county, making local market trends important for both buyers and sellers."

For a buyer weighing Hamilton against Zeeland, that means two things. You have more homes to choose from on both sides than you did a year ago. But in the Hamilton area you're competing with a growing pool of buyers who signed contracts in September, so the extra choice won't feel the same in 49419 as it does in Zeeland. A well-priced Hamilton listing that sits for a while is the exception this fall. And because the county median is pulled down by mix, comparing an asking price to $340,000 will make many Hamilton homes look overpriced when they aren't. Compare them to recent closed sales of similar homes in the same township.

A Hamilton seller is in a better position than the headline drop suggests. Contract activity in Allegan was rising into fall, and October's days on market were shorter than a year earlier. Your price should come from nearby sales of homes like yours, not from the county figure in either direction. For a free starting point, try the home valuation tool.

Both sides should keep in mind that country property around Hamilton has its own line items that county figures never show. A Hamilton price comparison is incomplete until it covers the well and septic evaluation, how a private road affects the closing timeline, and why the tax bill on the listing changes after a sale. Those factors don't change with a monthly report, and they affect what a particular house costs to own far more than a few percentage points of county median.

A few direct answers

Are Hamilton home prices falling? Allegan County's median fell 5.3% in September 2026 and 6.2% in October 2026 compared with the same months in 2025. Over the same months, Allegan's pending sales rose and its luxury sales more than doubled. That combination points to more modestly priced homes selling, not existing homes losing value across the board. Recent closed sales near a specific property are the better guide.

Is Zeeland getting more expensive? Ottawa County's median rose 7.5% in October 2026 while closed sales fell 20%. When fewer homes sell and the remaining sales lean higher, the median goes up without every home gaining value. Zeeland's own recent sales by neighborhood will tell you more than the county figure.

When will the next numbers come out? WMLAR released its October 2026 report on November 9, 2026, and its September pending sales on October 15, 2026, so the November figures should follow on a similar monthly schedule. The September pending count is the figure to compare against the next report.

If you're weighing a home near Hamilton against one in Zeeland or Holland this winter, Taressa at Sprick Homes can walk you through recent sales near the homes you're comparing, so you're judging each one on its own numbers instead of the county median. Schedule a free consultation, and bring the listings you've been comparing.

Let’s Find Your Dream Home

Get assistance in determining the current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram